This Make-Ahead Mac and Cheese is the recipe of your dreams. It's ultra-creamy, irresistibly cheesy, but best of all perfect for prepping ahead! Whether you make it today, prep ahead, or freeze it for later, this baked mac and cheese will be ready for your next craving.
Skip to:
Make-Ahead Mac and Cheese baked in the oven until ultra creamy is, for obvious reasons, a go-to recipe around here. It is the ultimate comfort food, satisfying to the very core. I might just put this one on a weekly rotation. 😆
We have been making this particular recipe for many years. The original is from America’s Test Kitchen and is almost perfect. My favorite part is that it uses a bit of chicken stock to thin the sauce, which preserves the creamy sauce-to-pasta ratio when it bakes and is made ahead/frozen.
But, as we tend to do, we did make a few changes. We prefer mac and cheese without bread crumbs (😬 I know, we're weird), so we removed that. We also added onion to the sauce for flavor and slightly adjusted the cheese combination for the creamiest, most flavorful cheese sauce possible. Now it is THE best mac and cheese recipe! If you are in a hurry there is always this easy mac and cheese that's done in 20 minutes on the stovetop.
We love make ahead recipes because they keep the craziness of mealtime at bay, especially during the holiday season. These make-ahead creamy scalloped potatoes (amazing holiday side dish!) or this loaded baked potato casserole are great additions to your freezer friendly recipes.
🧀 Ingredients
Macaroni: This is the classic elbow macaroni, but any tubular pasta will work.
Butter: I use salted. If you use unsalted, you may need to add additional salt later.
Onion and garlic: Preferably use fresh for both, but garlic powder or onion powder can be substituted in a pinch.
Dry mustard powder and cayenne pepper: Adds a little extra depth of flavor.
Flour: Makes the roux, which is the key to thickening the sauce.
Chicken broth: The extra ingredient for creating the perfect sauce consistency.
Milk: Whole milk makes all the difference. I don’t recommend substituting for 2% or less.
Cheese - Colby, Mozzarella, and Sharp Cheddar: This is my favorite combination of cheeses, but see below for substitution options.
Salt and black pepper: To round off the perfect flavor. You won’t need much.
🔪How to make mac and cheese
Note: I like to use a food processor to prep the onion and shred the cheese. Of course, those steps can be done by hand as well.
Start by boiling the macaroni, being sure to drain it when it is still slightly underdone and rinse it with cold water. It will continue cooking while it bakes.
For the sauce, melt butter in a pot on the stove over medium heat and cook the onion until it is soft and translucent.
Add the garlic, dry mustard powder, and cayenne for 30 seconds.
Cook flour in butter for 1 minute, stirring constantly.
Once flour is cooked, whisk in the milk and chicken broth. Cook until thick.
Before moving on, be sure to test the thickness on the back of a cooking spoon. The line of sauce should hold when a finger swipes it.
Whisk in blend of cheeses. Stir until fully combined.
My secret to perfectly smooth, even creamier sauce is to use an immersion blender once the cheese is melted. A quick blend for 1-2 minutes evens out the little bits of onion and cheese and creates the PERFECT creamy texture you’re going for.
Lightly rinse the cooked macaroni to help them separate. Then pour the noodles into the pot of sauce and stir to combine. Spray a 9x13 pan with non-stick spray or line with foil, and place pan on rimmed baking sheet to catch any overflow. Pour the noodles and sauce into the pan and bake until golden and bubbly.
Make-ahead instructions
To make this creamy baked mac and cheese ahead of time, pour it into a prepared pan and cool to room temperature. Cover with plastic wrap and then a layer of aluminum foil. Either refrigerate for up to three days or freeze up to three months. If frozen, thaw it overnight in the fridge the day before serving. Then bake per the recipe and serve it up!
👨👩👧👦 For a crowd
Mac and Cheese is always a crowd-pleaser! This recipe serves 8-10 for dinner. If you want to serve more, just double the recipe and bake it in two 9x13 pans. You will want to make the sauce in a very large saucepan, or make two separate batches. If you are only serving this as a side dish, one recipe will feed between 12-15 people.
🙋 Questions & Answers
My favorite cheese combination is sharp cheddar (for flavor), colby jack (a good melting cheese), and a bit of mozzarella (for extra creaminess). I don’t recommend substituting the sharp cheddar because it creates the main flavor profile. But you can substitute the other types of cheese with monterey jack, pepper jack, or any other good melting cheeses. Just know that it may come out slightly different than our original cheese combo.
If stored in an airtight container, it typically lasts 3-4 days and maintains it’s sauciness well. A quick reheat in the microwave is all it needs. If it seems a little dry when reheating, add a small splash of milk as it heats and stir well to incorporate.
📖 More recipes
- 25 Minute Lemon Broccoli Pasta - This is a super easy weeknight dinner with the most impressive flavors. It even sneaks in extra veggies! It's a busy night winner every time!
- Easy Chicken Piccata Pasta - This recipe uses bow tie pasta and ready-made chicken piccata to form a delicious, restaurant worthy pasta. It's great for an easy weeknight dinner, but equally worthy of serving guest on the weekend.
- AMAZING Spicy Chicken Sandwiches - Crispy, juicy, and covered in a sticky hot honey sauce. These might be one of the best sandwiches we've ever eaten.
- Stovetop Mac and Cheese - A great side dish made with the perfect amount of mozzarella cheese and extra-sharp cheddar cheese in just 20 minutes!
👨🏼🍳 Tips & Tricks
- Shred your own cheese - really! Pre- shredded cheese is coated, so it doesn't melt the same, nor does it have the same flavor.
- Cook your pasta slightly under al dente and rinse it with cold water immediately after draining. The cold rinse will stop the noodles from continuing to cook. This way they will finish cooking while baking without becoming bloated or soggy.
- Spray your pan lightly with non-stick spray to prevent the sauce from sticking. You can also line the pan with tinfoil and then lightly spray it.
- Use an immersion blender to make the finished sauce ultra smooth and creamy. This is my best secret! Sometimes cheese melts a little unevenly and the onions leave little flecks in the sauce... the immersion blender solves this problem perfectly every time.
👋🏻 Connect with us!
If you try this recipe, please leave a comment and star rating to let us know how it is! We’d also love to connect with you on Facebook, Instagram, or Pinterest. Tag @borrowedbites or hashtag #borrowedbites to show us your food!
📋 Recipe
Make-Ahead Mac and Cheese (Baked!)
Equipment
- Food processor optional
- whisk
Ingredients
- 1 lb elbow macaroni
- 6 tablespoon butter
- 1 medium onion finely diced
- 1 teaspoon garlic minced
- 1 teaspoon dry mustard
- ¼ teaspoon cayenne pepper
- 6 tablespoon flour
- 2¼ cups chicken broth
- 3½ cups whole milk
- 11 oz colby jack cheese shredded
- 5 oz mozzarella cheese shredded
- 8 oz sharp cheddar cheese shredded
- ¼ tsp pepper
- ¼ teaspoon kosher salt if needed
- non-stick spray
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 400°F. Lightly spray a 9x13 baking pan with non-stick cooking spray.non-stick spray
- Bring a large pot of water to a boil and add ½ tablespoon of kosher salt. Cook the pasta according to package directions, cooking 2 minutes less than directed. Drain and rinse briefly with cold water. Set aside.1 lb elbow macaroni
- In a large pot, melt butter. Add onions, cooking until soft and translucent, 3-4 minutes. Add garlic, dry mustard and cayenne and cook until fragrant, 30 seconds - 1 minute. Add flour, whisking constantly for 1 minute.6 tablespoon butter, 1 medium onion, 1 teaspoon garlic, 1 teaspoon dry mustard, ¼ teaspoon cayenne pepper, 6 tablespoon flour
- Slowly add the chicken broth and whole milk, whisking constantly, until flour mixture is completely incorporated. Bring to a simmer and cook, stirring OFTEN, until slightly thickened, 15-20 minutes. Thickness Test: When you draw a finger through the sauce across the back of spoon, the sauce should hold the line with no drips.2¼ cups chicken broth, 3½ cups whole milk
- Remove the sauce from the heat. Gradually whisk in the cheese, one type at a time, until fully melted. This may take a few minutes. Season with pepper and salt (if needed). Using an immersion blender, blend the sauce for 1-2 minutes until it is completely smooth.11 oz colby jack cheese, 5 oz mozzarella cheese, 8 oz sharp cheddar cheese, ¼ teaspoon pepper, ¼ teaspoon kosher salt
- Briefly rinse the noodles to help them separate. Pour noodles into the sauce, mixing until well combined. Pour pasta into the prepared pan and bake until hot and bubbly, about 30 minutes. Enjoy!
- We love comments! Please come back and leave us one after you’ve tried this recipe.
Notes
- Shred your own cheese - really! Pre- shredded cheese is coated, so it doesn't melt the same, nor does it have the same flavor.
- Use a block of mozzarella, not the ball. The ball of mozzarella has too much moisture.
- Cook your pasta slightly under and rinse it with cold water immediately after draining. The cold rinse will stop the noodles from continuing to cook. This way they will finish cooking while baking without becoming bloated or soggy.
- Spray your pan lightly with non-stick spray to prevent the sauce from sticking. You can also line the pan with tinfoil and then lightly spray it.
- Use an immersion blender to make the finished sauce ultra smooth and creamy. This is my best secret! Sometimes cheese melts a little unevenly and the onions leave little flecks in the sauce... the immersion blender solves this problem perfectly every time.
Add Your Own Notes
Nutrition
All nutrition information is provided by a third party and is an estimate only. Use your own nutritional calculator for more specific measurements.
TK says
The baked macaroni and cheese dish was a success with clamoring for more from a family of five! Thank you, the directions were easy to follow. I did discover not all onions are created equal :). The one I had was "hot" even though I sauteed it. Good thing I used only half of the called for amount. It was a tasty dish enjoyed by a two-year-old, a first-grader, a fifth-grader, and two adults for more than one meal on a cold night. Loved it!
Misty says
Glad you enjoyed it!
Sara says
I made this for a kid-friendly dish at a pot luck and it was a hit. I made it a day ahead and baked it the next day and it was still moist and creamy. I did not have an immersion blender so I substituted 1 tsp onion powder for the onion and 1/2 tsp garlic powder for the garlic and it was great.
Danielle says
Thanks for the high praise! We really appreciate you taking the time to let us know. Happy Thanksgiving!
Amber says
Should the foil be removed if baking from the fridge? Or leave it on?
Danielle says
Great question! We will update the post to add in a note about this. I would bake with the foil off, but if it begins to brown too much go ahead and lightly cover it until fully hot and bubbly. Enjoy!
Janet Lewis says
The flavor profile is great but my mac and cheese turned out grainy. I added the cheese after the white sauce was cooked for 15 minutes simmering and removed from heat. I feel like it got grainy after being in the oven for 25 minutes at 400F. What am I doing wrong? Is 400F too hot? I had Sharp cheddar, Monterey Jack, Velveeta and small amount of gruyere cheese in them. Help! I want to make good Mac and Cheese!
Misty says
Hi Janet! Thanks for your question - creamy mac and cheese is a must! The texture of the sauce is very dependent on the types and amounts of cheese. Personally I have never tried Velveeta or Gruyere, but I would imagine that both should work. Did you blend the sauce with an immersion blender until it was ultra-smooth before baking? Every time I make this that is the step that transforms the sauce!
Janet Lewis says
Hi Misty,
Thank you for your swift reply. I did indeed use the immersion blender right before mixing with cooked pasta and it was smooth. I gave a portion to my sister in law for her to bake it for her family last night. I told her to bake at 350F to see if that made a difference. She said it wasn't grainy and it was so good. Also, another thing that might have affected my Mac and Cheese texture was I used Velveeta American Singles. I read I need to be using American cheese blocks since the Singles have more additives and maybe that was the culprit. I will try when I make that next time. Crossing my fingers... I will post again. Thank you!!!
Misty says
Great, I'm so glad her's turned out well! I would add that the reason we have success every time with this recipe is that we have tested the exact cheese type and amounts that work well. I would suggest trying the recipe exactly as written and following the tips and tricks. I think you will find that it is wonderfully creamy and flavorful that way!
Jenny says
Delicious! Made this last night for the my family and the other family in our “bubble”...it was a hit with everyone! Served it as a create your own Mac and cheese bar with add-in choices...Buffalo chicken, wilted spinach, bacon, and sautéed mushrooms. The perfect meal for a group. So glad I found this post/recipe! Thank you
Danielle says
Now that sounds amazing! I will borrow that idea for one of our Sunday Dinners with the family. Thanks for the feedback!
Days says
Can you use another kind of milk like low-fat milk instead of whole milk?
Misty says
Hi! You can use another milk if that is all you have, but it typically doesn't turn out as creamy if it has less fat content. Should still work though. Hope that helps!
Marcy says
I absolutely love the immersion blender trick. Sometimes it seems like my cheese just doesn’t quite melt all the way, but that does the trick! It was the smoothest homemade sauce I’ve made.
Misty says
Yes, that's a great trick, huh? I'm glad you found it helpful for making the sauce extra smooth.
Aspen says
This is probably the most flavorful mac and cheese I've ever had. I love it! Now I just have to try not to eat the whole pan by myself, ha!
Misty says
YES, I have the same problem... it's too delicious.
Karen says
Don't.Change.A.Thing.....this is so good.
Misty says
So glad you liked it!